Sugashima-class minesweeper vs Tir-class speedboat

APatrol & mine warfare vessels

Sugashima-class minesweeper

Minesweeper

Credit

Hunini · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Resized · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source ↗ · Modified

BPatrol & mine warfare vessels

Tir-class speedboat

Torpedo Boat

First system

Second system

At a glance

Side by side

Length comparisonOne shared metre scale

Sugashima-class minesweeperLength

57 m

Length source ↗

Tir-class speedboatLength

2.06 m

Length source ↗

Lengths retain their source configuration and measurement scope.

Sugashima-class minesweeperlarger figure on 3 of 4

Length+2667%
Beam+71%
Complement+700%

Tir-class speedboatlarger figure on 1 of 4

Speed+270%

Counts only measures both sources give with the same scope. A larger figure is not a better system.

Measured figures

Head to head

10 of 28 rows sourced on both sides

57m

2.06m

Length+2667%

All recorded figures & sources

57 m

Length

Single source

57 m (187 ft 0 in )^[source]

2.06 m

Length

Single source

21.13 m

x · source measurement 1

Single source

5.74 m

x · source measurement 2

Single source

69 ft 4 in (21.13 m) x 18 ft 10 in (5.74 m) x 6 ft 9 in (2.06 m)^[source]

9.8m

5.74m

Beam+71%

All recorded figures & sources

9.8 m

Beam

Single source

9.8 m (32 ft 2 in)^[source]

5.74 m

Beam

Single source

18 ft 10 in (5.74 m)^[source]

—

2.06m

Height

All recorded figures & sources

2.06 m

Height

Single source

6 ft 9 in (2.06 m)^[source]

650tfull load

26tstandard, 28 1⁄

DisplacementScopes differ

All recorded figures & sources

650 tonnes

full load

Single source

570 tonnes

standard

Single source

570 t (560 long tons ) standard 650 t (640 long tons ) full load^[source]

4 tonnes

full

Single source

26 tonnes

standard, 28 1⁄

Single source

26t standard, 28 ¼ t full^[source]

Complement+700%

All recorded figures & sources

48 people

Complement

Single source

48^[source]

6 people

Complement

Single source

6^[source]

26km/hMaximum; Speed

96km/hMaximum; Speed

Speed+270%

All recorded figures & sources

26 km/h

Maximum; Speed

Single source

14 kn (26 km/h; 16 mph)^[source]

96.304 km/h

Maximum; Speed

Single source

52 kn^[source]

—

830km@ 25 knots

Range

All recorded figures & sources

830 km

@ 25 knots

Single source

450 nmi (830 km) @ 25 knots^[source]

—

895kW

Power

All recorded figures & sources

894.839846 kW

3 diesels (type unknown), 3 DIO waterjets

Single source

3 1200hp diesels (type unknown), 3 DIO waterjets^[source]

Bars compare reported quantities only. A larger figure does not make a system better; configurations and test conditions differ.

Configuration

Details

Sugashima-class minesweeper and Tir-class speedboat configuration
Specification	Sugashima-class minesweeper	Tir-class speedboat
Name	Sugashima^[source]	Tir II (IPS 18)^[source]
Builders	NKK , Keihin Hitachi , Kanagawa USC , Keihin^[source]	—
Preceded by	Uwajima class^[source]	—
Succeeded by	Harishima class^[source]	—
Built	1996-2005^[source]	—
In commission	2001-present^[source]	—
Planned	12^[source]	—
Completed	12^[source]	—
Active	6^[source]	—
Lost	1^[source]	—
Retired	5^[source]	—
Type	Minesweeper^[source]	Torpedo Boat^[source]
Depth	4.4 m (14 ft 5 in)^[source]	—
Propulsion	2 × Mitsubishi 6NMU diesel electric engines 2 × shafts^[source]	2 shafts^[source]
Sensors & processing systems	OPS-39 surface-search radar OYQ-201 sonar ZQS-4 sonar^[source]	I-band navigation radar^[source]
Armament	1 × single JM61R-MS 20mm guns^[source]	x4 (2 twin mounts) 12.7 mm x2 21 inch torpedo tubes (compatible with either Chinese, North Korean, or Iranian torpedoes) x1 Dooshka 12.7 mm MG^[source]
Operators	—	Iran Syria^[source]
National origin	—	Iran^[source]
Source manufacturer statement	—	Built by Iranian Maritime Industries (a subsidiary of the state-owned DIO company), the Bavar-class missile-armed boats are being acquired to replace the Tir-II s.^[source]Only the subject, component or variant named in this passage; unresolved names do not create a manufacturer identity

FORCETALLY

Loading the evidence…

Preparing your view.

Sugashima-class minesweeper

Tir-class speedboat

Name

Sugashima^[source]

Tir II (IPS 18)^[source]

Builders

NKK , Keihin Hitachi , Kanagawa USC , Keihin^[source]

—

Preceded by

Uwajima class^[source]

—

Succeeded by

Harishima class^[source]

—

Built

1996-2005^[source]

—

In commission

2001-present^[source]

—

Planned

12^[source]

—

Completed

12^[source]

—

Active

6^[source]

—

Lost

1^[source]

—

Retired

5^[source]

—

Type

Minesweeper^[source]

Torpedo Boat^[source]

Depth

4.4 m (14 ft 5 in)^[source]

—

Propulsion

2 × Mitsubishi 6NMU diesel electric engines 2 × shafts^[source]

2 shafts^[source]

Sensors & processing systems

OPS-39 surface-search radar OYQ-201 sonar ZQS-4 sonar^[source]

I-band navigation radar^[source]

Armament

1 × single JM61R-MS 20mm guns^[source]

x4 (2 twin mounts) 12.7 mm x2 21 inch torpedo tubes (compatible with either Chinese, North Korean, or Iranian torpedoes) x1 Dooshka 12.7 mm MG^[source]

Operators

—

Iran Syria^[source]

National origin

—

Iran^[source]

Source manufacturer statement

—

Built by Iranian Maritime Industries (a subsidiary of the state-owned DIO company), the Bavar-class missile-armed boats are being acquired to replace the Tir-II s.^[source]Only the subject, component or variant named in this passage; unresolved names do not create a manufacturer identity