Kagitingan-class patrol craft vs SAS Charlotte Maxeke

AWarships

Kagitingan-class patrol craft

Coastal Patrol Interdiction Craft

BWarships

SAS Charlotte Maxeke

First system

Second system

Measured figures

Head to head

8 of 29 rows sourced on both sides

—

62m

Length

All recorded figures & sources

62 m

Length

Single source

62 m (203 ft)^[source]

—

7.6m

Beam

All recorded figures & sources

7.6 m

Beam

Single source

7.6 m (25 ft)^[source]

—

5.8mDraft

Draught

All recorded figures & sources

5.8 m

Draft

Single source

5.8 m (19 ft)^[source]

160 tons full load

1,454tSubmerged

Displacement

All recorded figures & sources

160 tons full load^[source]

1,454 tonnes

Submerged

Single source

1,454 t , submerged^[source]

Complement

All recorded figures & sources

30 people

Complement

Single source

30^[source]

30 people

Complement

Single source

30^[source]

39km/hMaximum

40km/hMaximum; Submerged

SpeedScopes differ

All recorded figures & sources

39 km/h

Maximum

Single source

21 knots (39 km/h) maximum^[source]

40 km/h

Maximum; Submerged

Single source

19 km/h

Maximum; Surfaced

Single source

10 knots (19 km/h), surfaced; 21.5 knots (40 km/h), submerged^[source]

4,300km

20,000kmat 10 kn (19 km/h; 12 mph), surfaced

Range

All recorded figures & sources

4,300 km

Range

Single source

2,300 nmi (4,300 km)^[source]

15,000 km

at 10 kn (19 km/h; 12 mph), snorkeling

Single source

20,000 km

at 10 kn (19 km/h; 12 mph), surfaced

Single source

740 km

at 4 kn (7.4 km/h; 4.6 mph), submerged

Single source

11,000 nmi (20,000 km; 13,000 mi) at 10 kn (19 km/h; 12 mph), surfaced, 8,000 nmi (15,000 km; 9,200 mi) at 10 kn (19 km/h; 12 mph), snorkeling , 400 nmi (740 km; 460 mi) at 4 kn (7.4 km/h; 4.6 mph), submerged^[source]

Bars compare reported quantities only. A larger figure does not make a system better; configurations and test conditions differ.

Configuration

Details

Kagitingan-class patrol craft and SAS Charlotte Maxeke configuration
Specification	Kagitingan-class patrol craft	SAS Charlotte Maxeke
Power	2 × 2,050 hp MTU16V538TB91 MD 871/30 16-cylinder diesels 2 × GM-EMD 6-71 auxiliary diesels 2 shafts 60 kW generator^[source]	Diesel-electric, 4 diesels, 1 shaft, 6,100 shp (4,500 kW)^[source]
Name	Kagitingan class^[source]	SAS Charlotte Maxeke^[source]
Builders	W. Muller Shipyard, Hamelin , Germany (PG-101 & PG-102); Cavite Naval Shipyard, Cavite City, Philippines (PG-103 & PG-104)^[source]	—
Operators	Philippine Navy^[source]	—
Planned	6^[source]	—
Completed	4^[source]	—
Canceled	2^[source]	—
Active	1^[source]	—
Retired	3^[source]	—
Type	Coastal Patrol Interdiction Craft^[source]	—
Sensors & processing systems	Furuno I-band navigation/surface search radar Selenia Elsag NA 10 Mod.0 GFCS Orion 10X fire control radar^[source]	Sonar : STN Atlas CSU-90; hull mounted and flank arrays Radar : Surface search I-band Optics : Zeiss non-hull penetrating optronic mast^[source]
Armament	1 × Emerlec EX-31 30mm/75 caliber twin guns 1 x Bofors Mark 3 40mm/60 caliber gun (on PB-104 only) 4 × 12.7 mm HMG 2 x 7.62 mm GPMG^[source]	8 × 21-inch (533 mm) torpedo tubes , 14 AEG SUT 264 torpedoes ; optional UGM-84 Harpoon integration^[source]
Source measurement	The vessels had a displacement of 132 tons and a top speed of 16 knots (30 km/h; 18 mph). The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30 mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Elsag NA10 Mod 0 fire control system and Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62 mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The Philippine Navy reportedly had problems keeping sailors training in their fire control and radar systems, which were themselves hard to maintain. The vessels were also grossly overpowered, having reportedly been designed with a top speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph) in mind.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The class has an unsuccessful design, underpowered being not able to achieve design speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph). Hull is of semi-planing type marine grade mild steel with a round mid body and a flat afterplane. Superstructure is marine aluminum alloy. Main deck watertight from stem to stern and to shell. Pilothouse steering and propulsion controls arranged to permit one-man controls. Communications systems installed adjacent to the pilot house and make them readily accessible.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Selenia Elsag NA-10 Mod 0 fire control system and Selenia Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage PG 102 and 104 had their Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret modernized, but this was later removed from PG-104 and replaced with a Bofors 40 mm L60 gun as per the latest picture available.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage	—
Namesake	—	Charlotte Maxeke , a South African religious leader and political activist^[source]
Operator	—	South African Navy^[source]
Builder	—	Howaldtswerke-Deutsche Werft, Kiel^[source]
Launched	—	4 May 2005^[source]
Commissioned	—	14 March 2007^[source]
Status	—	in active service^[source]
Class & type	—	Heroine-class submarine^[source]
Test depth	—	500 m (1,600 ft)^[source]
Electronic warfare & decoys	—	ESM : Grintek Avitronics, intercept + radar warning receiver ELINT : Saab S/UME-100 tactical electronic support measures^[source]

FORCETALLY

Loading the evidence…

Preparing your view.

Kagitingan-class patrol craft

SAS Charlotte Maxeke

Power

2 × 2,050 hp MTU16V538TB91 MD 871/30 16-cylinder diesels 2 × GM-EMD 6-71 auxiliary diesels 2 shafts 60 kW generator^[source]

Diesel-electric, 4 diesels, 1 shaft, 6,100 shp (4,500 kW)^[source]

Name

Kagitingan class^[source]

SAS Charlotte Maxeke^[source]

Builders

W. Muller Shipyard, Hamelin , Germany (PG-101 & PG-102); Cavite Naval Shipyard, Cavite City, Philippines (PG-103 & PG-104)^[source]

—

Operators

Philippine Navy^[source]

—

Planned

6^[source]

—

Completed

4^[source]

—

Canceled

2^[source]

—

Active

1^[source]

—

Retired

3^[source]

—

Type

Coastal Patrol Interdiction Craft^[source]

—

Sensors & processing systems

Furuno I-band navigation/surface search radar Selenia Elsag NA 10 Mod.0 GFCS Orion 10X fire control radar^[source]

Sonar : STN Atlas CSU-90; hull mounted and flank arrays Radar : Surface search I-band Optics : Zeiss non-hull penetrating optronic mast^[source]

Armament

1 × Emerlec EX-31 30mm/75 caliber twin guns 1 x Bofors Mark 3 40mm/60 caliber gun (on PB-104 only) 4 × 12.7 mm HMG 2 x 7.62 mm GPMG^[source]

8 × 21-inch (533 mm) torpedo tubes , 14 AEG SUT 264 torpedoes ; optional UGM-84 Harpoon integration^[source]

Source measurement

The vessels had a displacement of 132 tons and a top speed of 16 knots (30 km/h; 18 mph). The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30 mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Elsag NA10 Mod 0 fire control system and Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62 mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The Philippine Navy reportedly had problems keeping sailors training in their fire control and radar systems, which were themselves hard to maintain. The vessels were also grossly overpowered, having reportedly been designed with a top speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph) in mind.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The class has an unsuccessful design, underpowered being not able to achieve design speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph). Hull is of semi-planing type marine grade mild steel with a round mid body and a flat afterplane. Superstructure is marine aluminum alloy. Main deck watertight from stem to stern and to shell. Pilothouse steering and propulsion controls arranged to permit one-man controls. Communications systems installed adjacent to the pilot house and make them readily accessible.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Selenia Elsag NA-10 Mod 0 fire control system and Selenia Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

PG 102 and 104 had their Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret modernized, but this was later removed from PG-104 and replaced with a Bofors 40 mm L60 gun as per the latest picture available.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

—

Namesake

—

Charlotte Maxeke , a South African religious leader and political activist^[source]

Operator

—

South African Navy^[source]

Builder

—

Howaldtswerke-Deutsche Werft, Kiel^[source]

Launched

—

4 May 2005^[source]

Commissioned

—

14 March 2007^[source]

Status

—

in active service^[source]

Class & type

—

Heroine-class submarine^[source]

Test depth

—

500 m (1,600 ft)^[source]

Electronic warfare & decoys

—

ESM : Grintek Avitronics, intercept + radar warning receiver ELINT : Saab S/UME-100 tactical electronic support measures^[source]