Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship vs Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)

AWarships

Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship

Logistics ship

BWarships

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)

Credit

Bahnfrend · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Resized · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source ↗ · Modified

First system

Second system

At a glance

Side by side

Length comparisonOne shared metre scale

Isla Tiburón-class logistics shipLength

99.8 m

Length source ↗

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)Length

144.6 m

Length source ↗

Lengths retain their source configuration and measurement scope.

Isla Tiburón-class logistics shiplarger figure on 0 of 3

None

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)larger figure on 3 of 3

Length+45%
Beam+29%
Speed+31%

Counts only measures both sources give with the same scope. A larger figure is not a better system.

Measured figures

Head to head

7 of 37 rows sourced on both sides

99.8m

145m

Length+45%

All recorded figures & sources

99.8 m

Length

Single source

99.8 m (327 ft)^[source]

144.6 m

Length

Single source

474.41 ft (144.6 m)^[source]

15.24m

19.7m

Beam+29%

All recorded figures & sources

15.24 m

Beam

Single source

15.24 m (50.0 ft)^[source]

19.7 m

Beam

Single source

19.7 m (64.6 ft)^[source]

—

8.7m

Draught

All recorded figures & sources

8.7 m

Draught

Single source

8.7 m (28.5 ft)^[source]

3,666t

6,700 tons

Displacement

All recorded figures & sources

3,666 tonnes

Displacement

Single source

3,666 t (3,608 long tons)^[source]

6,700 tons^[source]

—

201

Complement

All recorded figures & sources

201 people

Complement

Single source

201^[source]

22km/hMaximum; Speed

29km/hMaximum; Speed

Speed+31%

All recorded figures & sources

22 km/h

Maximum; Speed

Single source

12 knots (22 km/h; 14 mph)^[source]

28.9 km/h

Maximum; Speed

Single source

50 km/h

Maximum; max cruise speed

Single source

27 knots (50 km/h; 31 mph); max cruise speed 15.6 knots (28.9 km/h; 18.0 mph)^[source]

—

12,600kmat 15 knots (28 km/h; 17 mph)

Range

All recorded figures & sources

12,600 km

at 15 knots (28 km/h; 17 mph)

Single source

6,800 nmi (12,600 km; 7,800 mi) at 15 knots (28 km/h; 17 mph)^[source]

Bars compare reported quantities only. A larger figure does not make a system better; configurations and test conditions differ.

Configuration

Details

Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship and Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593) configuration
Specification	Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship	Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)
Power	—	CODLAG 1 × 32 MW gas turbine General Electric/Avio LM2500+G4 2 × 2.5 MW electric motors Jeumont Electric 4 × diesel generators VL 1716 (T2ME series by 2,15 MW everyone, on first two frigate; HPCR series by 2,8 MW everyone, since the third frigate) 2 × shafts , driving controllable pitch propellers 1 × 1 MW bow thruster^[source]
Name	2011-2023 Montes Azules -class from 2023 Isla Tiburón -class^[source]	Carabiniere^[source]
Builders	ASTIMAR , Oaxaca^[source]	—
Operators	Mexican Navy^[source]	—
Succeeded by	Isla Madre class^[source]	—
In commission	2011-present^[source]	—
Planned	2^[source]	—
Completed	2^[source]	—
Active	2^[source]	—
Type	Logistics ship^[source]	—
Propulsion	2 × Diesel engines , 2 × shafts^[source]	—
Endurance	60 days^[source]	—
Boats & landing craft carried	2 × LCVPs^[source]	—
Troops	89 officers and enlisted men^[source]	—
Armament	5 × Bofors 40 mm guns^[source]	16-cell MBDA SYLVER A50 VLS for 16 MBDA Aster 15 and 30 missiles 2 × Leonardo OTO Melara 76/62 mm Davide/Strales CIWS guns 2 × Leonardo Oto Melara / Oerlikon KBA 25/80 mm remote weapon systems 4 × MBDA Teseo Mk-2/A anti-ship and land attack missiles 4 × MBDA MILAS anti-submarine missiles 2 x triple Leonardo (WASS) B-515/3 launcher for MU 90 torpedoes 2 x SITEP MASS CS-424 acoustic guns^[source]
Aviation facilities	Helipad^[source]	Double hangar^[source]
Source measurement	The BAL-02 is based on the concept of the Pánuco-class tank landing ships , they hold a crew of 89 members, including female personnel. Its length (length) is 99.80 meters, the beam (width) is 15.24 meters, it will reach a speed of up to 12 knots with an autonomy (maximum time without refueling) of 60 days and a maximum displacement of 3,666 tons. While the propulsion plant consists of two diesel internal combustion engines of 1,750 BHP at 1,000 RPM each.^[source]Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship · Design; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The Logistics Support Ships project was born from the need to rethink the definition of the basic characteristics of the surface units required by the Mexican Navy, to fulfill its mission in terms of supporting the civilian population in disaster areas, by transporting and disembarkation of vehicles, supplies and personnel on beaches and/or docks. they have a platform for the helicopter to takeoff and land ( MI-17 and UH-60 Black Hawk ) and a JP-5 fuel supply system for helicopters, with a storage capacity of 15,000 liters. In addition, it will have two landing craft with the capacity to transport personnel and load vehicles.^[source]Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship · Design; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage	—
Namesake	—	Carabiniere^[source]
Builder	—	Fincantieri , Riva Trigoso and Muggiano^[source]
Laid down	—	6 April 2011^[source]
Launched	—	29 March 2014^[source]
Commissioned	—	28 April 2015^[source]
Home port	—	Taranto^[source]
Identification	—	MMSI number : 247321700 Callsign : Pennant number : F 593^[source]
Motto	—	Nei secoli fedele (Forever faithful)^[source]
Status	—	Active^[source]
Class & type	—	Carlo Bergamini -class frigate^[source]
Sensors & processing systems	—	Leonardo Kronos Grand Naval (MFRA) Active electronically scanned array radar CAPTAS-4 towed-array sonar UMS 4110 CL hull-mounted sonar^[source]
Aircraft carried	—	2 × SH90 1 × SH90 1 × AW101 (armed with MU 90 torpedoes or MBDA Marte Mk2/S missiles)^[source]
Used by	—	Italian Navy^[source]Current operator stated in the article; inventory date not specified

FORCETALLY

Loading the evidence…

Preparing your view.

Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)

Power

—

CODLAG 1 × 32 MW gas turbine General Electric/Avio LM2500+G4 2 × 2.5 MW electric motors Jeumont Electric 4 × diesel generators VL 1716 (T2ME series by 2,15 MW everyone, on first two frigate; HPCR series by 2,8 MW everyone, since the third frigate) 2 × shafts , driving controllable pitch propellers 1 × 1 MW bow thruster^[source]

Name

2011-2023 Montes Azules -class from 2023 Isla Tiburón -class^[source]

Carabiniere^[source]

Builders

ASTIMAR , Oaxaca^[source]

—

Operators

Mexican Navy^[source]

—

Succeeded by

Isla Madre class^[source]

—

In commission

2011-present^[source]

—

Planned

2^[source]

—

Completed

2^[source]

—

Active

2^[source]

—

Type

Logistics ship^[source]

—

Propulsion

2 × Diesel engines , 2 × shafts^[source]

—

Endurance

60 days^[source]

—

Boats & landing craft carried

2 × LCVPs^[source]

—

Troops

89 officers and enlisted men^[source]

—

Armament

5 × Bofors 40 mm guns^[source]

16-cell MBDA SYLVER A50 VLS for 16 MBDA Aster 15 and 30 missiles 2 × Leonardo OTO Melara 76/62 mm Davide/Strales CIWS guns 2 × Leonardo Oto Melara / Oerlikon KBA 25/80 mm remote weapon systems 4 × MBDA Teseo Mk-2/A anti-ship and land attack missiles 4 × MBDA MILAS anti-submarine missiles 2 x triple Leonardo (WASS) B-515/3 launcher for MU 90 torpedoes 2 x SITEP MASS CS-424 acoustic guns^[source]

Aviation facilities

Helipad^[source]

Double hangar^[source]

Source measurement

The BAL-02 is based on the concept of the Pánuco-class tank landing ships , they hold a crew of 89 members, including female personnel. Its length (length) is 99.80 meters, the beam (width) is 15.24 meters, it will reach a speed of up to 12 knots with an autonomy (maximum time without refueling) of 60 days and a maximum displacement of 3,666 tons. While the propulsion plant consists of two diesel internal combustion engines of 1,750 BHP at 1,000 RPM each.^[source]Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship · Design; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The Logistics Support Ships project was born from the need to rethink the definition of the basic characteristics of the surface units required by the Mexican Navy, to fulfill its mission in terms of supporting the civilian population in disaster areas, by transporting and disembarkation of vehicles, supplies and personnel on beaches and/or docks. they have a platform for the helicopter to takeoff and land ( MI-17 and UH-60 Black Hawk ) and a JP-5 fuel supply system for helicopters, with a storage capacity of 15,000 liters. In addition, it will have two landing craft with the capacity to transport personnel and load vehicles.^[source]Isla Tiburón-class logistics ship · Design; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

—

Namesake

—

Carabiniere^[source]

Builder

—

Fincantieri , Riva Trigoso and Muggiano^[source]

Laid down

—

6 April 2011^[source]

Launched

—

29 March 2014^[source]

Commissioned

—

28 April 2015^[source]

Home port

—

Taranto^[source]

Identification

—

MMSI number : 247321700 Callsign : Pennant number : F 593^[source]

Motto

—

Nei secoli fedele (Forever faithful)^[source]

Status

—

Active^[source]

Class & type

—

Carlo Bergamini -class frigate^[source]

Sensors & processing systems

—

Leonardo Kronos Grand Naval (MFRA) Active electronically scanned array radar CAPTAS-4 towed-array sonar UMS 4110 CL hull-mounted sonar^[source]

Aircraft carried

—

2 × SH90 1 × SH90 1 × AW101 (armed with MU 90 torpedoes or MBDA Marte Mk2/S missiles)^[source]

Used by

—

Italian Navy^[source]Current operator stated in the article; inventory date not specified