INS Sagardhwani vs Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)

AWarships

INS Sagardhwani

Research ship

BWarships

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)

Credit

Bahnfrend · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Resized · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source ↗ · Modified

First system

Second system

At a glance

Side by side

Length comparisonOne shared metre scale

INS Sagardhwanio/a

85.1 m

Length source ↗

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)Length

144.6 m

Length source ↗

Lengths retain their source configuration and measurement scope.

INS Sagardhwanilarger figure on 1 of 2

Speed+4%

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)larger figure on 1 of 2

Beam+54%

Counts only measures both sources give with the same scope. A larger figure is not a better system.

Measured figures

Head to head

17 of 27 rows sourced on both sides

85.1mo/a

145m

Length

All recorded figures & sources

85.1 m

o/a

Single source

85.1 m (279 ft) o/a^[source]

144.6 m

Length

Single source

474.41 ft (144.6 m)^[source]

12.8m

19.7m

Beam+54%

All recorded figures & sources

12.8 m

Beam

Single source

12.8 m (42 ft)^[source]

19.7 m

Beam

Single source

19.7 m (64.6 ft)^[source]

—

8.7m

Draught

All recorded figures & sources

8.7 m

Draught

Single source

8.7 m (28.5 ft)^[source]

2,083tfull load

6,700 tons

Displacement

All recorded figures & sources

2,083 tonnes

full load

Single source

2,050 long tons (2,083 t ) full load^[source]

6,700 tons^[source]

80, plus 16 scientists

201

Complement

All recorded figures & sources

80, plus 16 scientists^[source]

201 people

Complement

Single source

201^[source]

30km/hMaximum; Speed

29km/hMaximum; Speed

Speed+4%

All recorded figures & sources

30 km/h

Maximum; Speed

Single source

16 knots (30 km/h; 18 mph)^[source]

28.9 km/h

Maximum; Speed

Single source

50 km/h

Maximum; max cruise speed

Single source

27 knots (50 km/h; 31 mph); max cruise speed 15.6 knots (28.9 km/h; 18.0 mph)^[source]

11,000kmat 16 kn (30 km/h; 18 mph)

12,600kmat 15 knots (28 km/h; 17 mph)

RangeScopes differ

All recorded figures & sources

11,000 km

at 16 kn (30 km/h; 18 mph)

Single source

6,000 nmi (11,000 km) at 16 kn (30 km/h; 18 mph)^[source]

12,600 km

at 15 knots (28 km/h; 17 mph)

Single source

6,800 nmi (12,600 km; 7,800 mi) at 15 knots (28 km/h; 17 mph)^[source]

Bars compare reported quantities only. A larger figure does not make a system better; configurations and test conditions differ.

Configuration

Details

INS Sagardhwani and Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593) configuration
Specification	INS Sagardhwani	Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)
Power	2 × diesel engines 3,860 hp (2,880 kW) sustained 2 shafts 2 auxiliary thrusters^[source]	CODLAG 1 × 32 MW gas turbine General Electric/Avio LM2500+G4 2 × 2.5 MW electric motors Jeumont Electric 4 × diesel generators VL 1716 (T2ME series by 2,15 MW everyone, on first two frigate; HPCR series by 2,8 MW everyone, since the third frigate) 2 × shafts , driving controllable pitch propellers 1 × 1 MW bow thruster^[source]
Name	INS Sagardhwani^[source]	Carabiniere^[source]
Builder	Garden Reach Shipbuilders & Engineers , Kolkata^[source]	Fincantieri , Riva Trigoso and Muggiano^[source]
Launched	May 1991^[source]	29 March 2014^[source]
Commissioned	30 July 1994^[source]	28 April 2015^[source]
Home port	Kochi , India^[source]	Taranto^[source]
Identification	IMO number : 8802818 Callsign : VVXQ^[source]	MMSI number : 247321700 Callsign : Pennant number : F 593^[source]
Status	Active^[source]	Active^[source]
Type	Research ship^[source]	—
Endurance	200 days^[source]	—
Sensors & processing systems	Racal Decca 1629 radar at I-band frequency^[source]	Leonardo Kronos Grand Naval (MFRA) Active electronically scanned array radar CAPTAS-4 towed-array sonar UMS 4110 CL hull-mounted sonar^[source]
Aircraft carried	1 × HAL Chetak^[source]	2 × SH90 1 × SH90 1 × AW101 (armed with MU 90 torpedoes or MBDA Marte Mk2/S missiles)^[source]
Aviation facilities	Helicopter landing pad^[source]	Double hangar^[source]
Source measurement	Internally, the ship has eight laboratories for various scientific disciplines, and a mini-operating theatre with medical staff. At the stern is handling equipment for mooring and retrieving oceanographic and acoustic buoys. It can accommodate up to 82 persons, including 16 scientists, and a crew of 8 officers and 58 sailors.^[source]INS Sagardhwani · Lead; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage	—
Namesake	—	Carabiniere^[source]
Laid down	—	6 April 2011^[source]
Motto	—	Nei secoli fedele (Forever faithful)^[source]
Class & type	—	Carlo Bergamini -class frigate^[source]
Armament	—	16-cell MBDA SYLVER A50 VLS for 16 MBDA Aster 15 and 30 missiles 2 × Leonardo OTO Melara 76/62 mm Davide/Strales CIWS guns 2 × Leonardo Oto Melara / Oerlikon KBA 25/80 mm remote weapon systems 4 × MBDA Teseo Mk-2/A anti-ship and land attack missiles 4 × MBDA MILAS anti-submarine missiles 2 x triple Leonardo (WASS) B-515/3 launcher for MU 90 torpedoes 2 x SITEP MASS CS-424 acoustic guns^[source]
Used by	—	Italian Navy^[source]Current operator stated in the article; inventory date not specified

FORCETALLY

Loading the evidence…

Preparing your view.

INS Sagardhwani

Italian frigate Carabiniere (F 593)

Power

2 × diesel engines 3,860 hp (2,880 kW) sustained 2 shafts 2 auxiliary thrusters^[source]

CODLAG 1 × 32 MW gas turbine General Electric/Avio LM2500+G4 2 × 2.5 MW electric motors Jeumont Electric 4 × diesel generators VL 1716 (T2ME series by 2,15 MW everyone, on first two frigate; HPCR series by 2,8 MW everyone, since the third frigate) 2 × shafts , driving controllable pitch propellers 1 × 1 MW bow thruster^[source]

Name

INS Sagardhwani^[source]

Carabiniere^[source]

Builder

Garden Reach Shipbuilders & Engineers , Kolkata^[source]

Fincantieri , Riva Trigoso and Muggiano^[source]

Launched

May 1991^[source]

29 March 2014^[source]

Commissioned

30 July 1994^[source]

28 April 2015^[source]

Home port

Kochi , India^[source]

Taranto^[source]

Identification

IMO number : 8802818 Callsign : VVXQ^[source]

MMSI number : 247321700 Callsign : Pennant number : F 593^[source]

Status

Active^[source]

Type

Research ship^[source]

—

Endurance

200 days^[source]

—

Sensors & processing systems

Racal Decca 1629 radar at I-band frequency^[source]

Leonardo Kronos Grand Naval (MFRA) Active electronically scanned array radar CAPTAS-4 towed-array sonar UMS 4110 CL hull-mounted sonar^[source]

Aircraft carried

1 × HAL Chetak^[source]

2 × SH90 1 × SH90 1 × AW101 (armed with MU 90 torpedoes or MBDA Marte Mk2/S missiles)^[source]

Aviation facilities

Helicopter landing pad^[source]

Double hangar^[source]

Source measurement

Internally, the ship has eight laboratories for various scientific disciplines, and a mini-operating theatre with medical staff. At the stern is handling equipment for mooring and retrieving oceanographic and acoustic buoys. It can accommodate up to 82 persons, including 16 scientists, and a crew of 8 officers and 58 sailors.^[source]INS Sagardhwani · Lead; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

—

Namesake

—

Carabiniere^[source]

Laid down

—

6 April 2011^[source]

Motto

—

Nei secoli fedele (Forever faithful)^[source]

Class & type

—

Carlo Bergamini -class frigate^[source]

Armament

—

16-cell MBDA SYLVER A50 VLS for 16 MBDA Aster 15 and 30 missiles 2 × Leonardo OTO Melara 76/62 mm Davide/Strales CIWS guns 2 × Leonardo Oto Melara / Oerlikon KBA 25/80 mm remote weapon systems 4 × MBDA Teseo Mk-2/A anti-ship and land attack missiles 4 × MBDA MILAS anti-submarine missiles 2 x triple Leonardo (WASS) B-515/3 launcher for MU 90 torpedoes 2 x SITEP MASS CS-424 acoustic guns^[source]

Used by

—

Italian Navy^[source]Current operator stated in the article; inventory date not specified