Gepard-class frigate vs Kagitingan-class patrol craft

FORCETALLY

Loading the evidence…

Preparing your view.

Gepard-class frigate — licensed reference photograph

AWarships

Gepard-class frigate

Frigate

Credit

Vissarion · Public domain · Resized · Public domain · Source ↗ · Modified

BWarships

Kagitingan-class patrol craft

Coastal Patrol Interdiction Craft

First system

Second system

At a glance

Side by side

Gepard-class frigatelarger figure on 1 of 1

Complement+213%

Kagitingan-class patrol craftlarger figure on 0 of 1

None

Counts only measures both sources give with the same scope. A larger figure is not a better system.

Measured figures

Head to head

13 of 30 rows sourced on both sides

≈ 102mApprox Gepard 3.9 batch II

—

Length

All recorded figures & sources

≈ 102.4 m

Approx Gepard 3.9 batch II

Single source

Approx 102.4 m (336 ft) (Gepard 3.9 batch II)^[source]

15mGepard 3.9

Configuration

Details

Gepard-class frigate and Kagitingan-class patrol craft configuration
Specification	Gepard-class frigate	Kagitingan-class patrol craft
Displacement	1,500 tons (standard) 2,500 tons (Gepard 3.9)^[source]	160 tons full load^[source]
Power	—	2 × 2,050 hp MTU16V538TB91 MD 871/30 16-cylinder diesels 2 × GM-EMD 6-71 auxiliary diesels 2 shafts 60 kW generator^[source]
Name	Gepard class (Project 1166.1)^[source]	Kagitingan class^[source]
Builders	Zelenodolsk Plant Gorky^[source]	W. Muller Shipyard, Hamelin , Germany (PG-101 & PG-102); Cavite Naval Shipyard, Cavite City, Philippines (PG-103 & PG-104)

Operators	Russian Navy Vietnam People's Navy^[source]	Philippine Navy^[source]

Preceded by	Koni class Grisha class^[source]	—

Subclasses	Project 11661 Tatarstan Project 11661K Dagestan Project 11661E Gepard: Gepard 3.9: Batch I; Batch II Gepard 5.1 Gepard 5.3^[source]	—

Cost	11661E (Gepard 3.9 batch I): US$175 million per ship 11661E (Gepard 3.9 batch II): US$350 million per ship (price included ammunition, maintenance packages signed between Vietnam and Russia )^[source]	—

Built	1991–2016^[source]	—

Planned	10^[source]	6^[source]

Completed	6^[source]	4^[source]

Cancelled	2^[source]	—

Active	6^[source]	1^[source]

Type	Frigate^[source]	Coastal Patrol Interdiction Craft^[source]

Propulsion	Twin-shaft CODOG , FPP, 2 × 14,300 + 1 × 6,000 (kW)^[source]	—

Endurance	20 days^[source]	—

Sensors & processing systems	MR-231-1 Pal navigation radar Mineral-ME shipborne multifunctional radar system (including guidance and target designation functions for cruise missiles ) 5P-26/MR-352 Pozitiv-ME1/-ME1.2 3D active shipborne radars 5P-10E-03E Laska fire control radar for naval gun and CIWS Sonar : MGK-335EM-03 with under-keel antenna^[source]	Furuno I-band navigation/surface search radar Selenia Elsag NA 10 Mod.0 GFCS Orion 10X fire control radar^[source]

Electronic warfare & decoys	EW Suite : 2 × Bell Shroud passive intercept, 2 × Bell Squat jammers, Countermeasures : 4 × 16-barreled Pk-16 decoy launchers^[source]	—

Armament	Artillery: 1 × 76.2mm AK-176M/MA naval gun 2 × AK-630M CIWS ( Tatarstan and VPN configuration) Cruise missiles : 8 × UKSK VLS cells for Kalibr missiles ( Dagestan ) (up to 16x cells in configurations offered to the export market; options for Club-N , Yakhont and BrahMos missile systems are available) 2 × quadruple launchers (2×4) Kh-35 anti-ship missiles ( Tatarstan and VPN 's Batch I & II configuration) Anti-submarine warfare : 2 × 533mm DTA-53 twin-tube (2×2) torpedo launchers (not featured on VPN 's Batch I) Naval mines Anti-air warfare : 1 × Palash/Palma-SU CIWS featured with 8x Sosna-R short range air defense missiles ( Dagestan and VPN configuration) 1 × Osa-M twin-launcher for 20x 9M33M short range air defense missiles ( Tatarstan ) 12 × Shtil-1 VLS cells for 9M317ME medium-range surface-to-air missiles (offered configuration for the export market)^[source]	1 × Emerlec EX-31 30mm/75 caliber twin guns 1 x Bofors Mark 3 40mm/60 caliber gun (on PB-104 only) 4 × 12.7 mm HMG 2 x 7.62 mm GPMG^[source]

Notes	[1]^[source]	—

National origin	Russia^[source]	—

Canceled	—	2^[source]

Retired	—	3^[source]

Source measurement	—	The vessels had a displacement of 132 tons and a top speed of 16 knots (30 km/h; 18 mph). The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30 mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Elsag NA10 Mod 0 fire control system and Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62 mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The Philippine Navy reportedly had problems keeping sailors training in their fire control and radar systems, which were themselves hard to maintain. The vessels were also grossly overpowered, having reportedly been designed with a top speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph) in mind.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The class has an unsuccessful design, underpowered being not able to achieve design speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph). Hull is of semi-planing type marine grade mild steel with a round mid body and a flat afterplane. Superstructure is marine aluminum alloy. Main deck watertight from stem to stern and to shell. Pilothouse steering and propulsion controls arranged to permit one-man controls. Communications systems installed adjacent to the pilot house and make them readily accessible.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Selenia Elsag NA-10 Mod 0 fire control system and Selenia Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage PG 102 and 104 had their Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret modernized, but this was later removed from PG-104 and replaced with a Bofors 40 mm L60 gun as per the latest picture available.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

Source measurement

—

The vessels had a displacement of 132 tons and a top speed of 16 knots (30 km/h; 18 mph). The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30 mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Elsag NA10 Mod 0 fire control system and Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62 mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The Philippine Navy reportedly had problems keeping sailors training in their fire control and radar systems, which were themselves hard to maintain. The vessels were also grossly overpowered, having reportedly been designed with a top speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph) in mind.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · History; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The class has an unsuccessful design, underpowered being not able to achieve design speed of 28 knots (52 km/h; 32 mph). Hull is of semi-planing type marine grade mild steel with a round mid body and a flat afterplane. Superstructure is marine aluminum alloy. Main deck watertight from stem to stern and to shell. Pilothouse steering and propulsion controls arranged to permit one-man controls. Communications systems installed adjacent to the pilot house and make them readily accessible.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

The main armament was a single powered Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret with two 30mm cannons mounted forward of the main superstructure. The weapon system linked to an Selenia Elsag NA-10 Mod 0 fire control system and Selenia Orion 10X fire control radar. Four .50 caliber and two 7.62mm machine guns complimented this system. Philippine sailors were sent to Europe to familiarize themselves with this new system, unlike the existing manually operated turrets with manual fire control systems.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage

PG 102 and 104 had their Emerlec EX 34 Mod 0 turret modernized, but this was later removed from PG-104 and replaced with a Bofors 40 mm L60 gun as per the latest picture available.^[source]Kagitingan-class patrol craft · Technical details; only the objects and conditions stated in this passage